Duck · breed notes
Black East Indian Duck
The Black East Indian is a small, dark bantam duck whose plumage carries a greenish tint. These two early books describe its head, color, habits, and the places where their accounts differ.
What kind of duck it is
Howard places the Black East Indian with the Call as one of the bantam breeds of ducks. Lamon and Slocum describe it as a small black breed and make the comparison more specific: in their account, it is a miniature Cayuga. Neither passage gives a place of origin for the breed.
The Black East Indian and the Call ducks are the bantam breeds of ducks
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThis is a black breed which is small in size being a bantam duck like the Call.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
As a matter of fact it is a miniature Cayuga.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
The two entries are brief in different ways. Howard gives the Black East Indian a place among the small exhibition ducks, while Lamon and Slocum use the Cayuga as the comparison point for its type and color. The books do not give a founding country, a date, or a story of how the breed began.
The Black East Indian and the Call ducks are the bantam breeds of ducks
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThe color should be black throughout and the same color characteristics hold true as in the case of the Cayuga.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
How to recognise one
Start with the head. Howard describes it as short and small, with dark hazel eyes and a rather short bill. The drake has a dark yellowish green head without spots or blemishes, while the duck is very dark, almost black. Lamon and Slocum make the drake bill a very dark green and the duck bill black.
The head of the black East Indian duck is short and small; eyes dark hazel; bill rather short.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThe head of the drake is of a dark yellowish green, free from all spots or blemishes, and the duck's head is very dark, almost black.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Managementthe bill of the duck should be black but that of the drake should be very dark green.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
The plumage is meant to read as black first, with color appearing as a sheen rather than a separate pattern. Howard calls it rich black with a brilliant greenish tint throughout and says the neck, back, and shoulder coverts show more green than the underparts. Lamon and Slocum also require black throughout and warn about white in the breast of females.
The plumage is a rich black, with a brilliant greenish tint throughout.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThe plumage upon the neck, back, and shoulder coverts will show more of the green than will the underparts
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (1)
the worst one being white in the breast of females especially.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
The rest of the outline is compact but not round. Howard gives a neatly curved short neck, a good-length medium-width back, a full and round breast, a long comparatively small body, medium wings that fold neatly, and a short tail. The drake has curled feathers in that tail; the thighs and shanks are short.
The neck is neatly curved and short; back, of good length and medium width.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThe breast is full, round, and plump. The body is long and comparatively small; wings of medium length and nicely folded; tail short, and in the drake has the curled feathers.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (1)
The thighs are short and stout, and shanks are short and rather small.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
Temperament and habits
Howard presents the Black East Indian as a shy, roaming bird. It is given to long flights, does not do well when confined, and prefers freedom of life. That makes its behavior part of the breed portrait, not just a note about its appearance.
The East Indian duck is very shy in its habits, and is given to long flights
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThey can not be successfully bred in confinement; their natures are roaming and they like freedom of life.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
The sitting habit is one of the clearest points the books attach to this small breed. Howard calls these ducks splendid sitters and says they will steal their nests if permitted to do so. Lamon and Slocum place the Black East India among the broody breeds.
They are splendid sitters, and will invariably steal their nests if permitted to do so
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThe Muscovy, the Call and the Black East India ducks are broody breeds.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
Lamon and Slocum give a short practical warning about the bill: the drake should not have a black bill, and the breed differs from the Cayuga in that the drake bill should be very dark green. Their entry also says purple barring should be selected against, so the desired black is not simply any dark-looking pattern.
Avoid breeding from a drake with a black bill
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and GeesePurple barring must be carefully selected against.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
The two books side by side
| Point | Howard, 1897 | Lamon & Slocum, 1922 |
|---|---|---|
| Plumage | Rich black with a brilliant greenish tint“The plumage is a rich black, with a brilliant greenish tint throughout.” (Howard, 1897) | Black throughout“The color should be black throughout” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Head | Drake dark yellowish green; duck very dark, almost black“The head of the drake is of a dark yellowish green, free from all spots or blemishes, and the duck's head is very dark, almost black.” (Howard, 1897) | Not described in this book |
| Bill | Another raiser called the drake bill olive green“By another raiser the color of the bill is described as an olive green.” (Howard, 1897) | Duck black; drake very dark green“the bill of the duck should be black but that of the drake should be very dark green.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Eyes | Dark hazel“eyes dark hazel” (Howard, 1897) | Not described in this book |
| Body outline | Long, comparatively small body; short tail“The body is long and comparatively small; wings of medium length and nicely folded; tail short” (Howard, 1897) | Not described in this book |
| Faults named | White feathers, especially about the eyes and breast“The white feathers usually appear about the eyes and also upon the breast.” (Howard, 1897) | White in the breast of females; purple barring“the worst one being white in the breast of females especially.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
No standard weight
Neither book gives a standard weight for the Black East Indian. Howard gives an exhibition-related size statement, while Lamon and Slocum give rough drake and duck ranges in the same passage.
As printed in Howard, 1897: There is no standard weight given for Black East Indians; the smaller their size the higher they rank for exhibition purposes.
As printed in Lamon & Slocum, 1922: There are no standard weights for the Call duck and for the Black East India duck but these are all small in size, being really bantam ducks. The drakes will weigh from 2-1/2 to 3 pounds and the ducks from 2 to 2-1/2 pounds.
Where the two books disagree
The books describe the Black East Indian drake bill differently. Howard records one raiser calling it olive green, while Lamon and Slocum require a very dark green drake bill and a black duck bill; this page leaves the descriptions side by side.
By another raiser the color of the bill is described as an olive green.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
the bill of the duck should be black but that of the drake should be very dark green.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
Questions readers ask
How large was the Black East Indian duck in these accounts?
Howard says it seldom grew larger than 2 to 2½ pounds each. Lamon and Slocum say there was no standard weight for the breed, then give the drakes as 2-1/2 to 3 pounds and the ducks as 2 to 2-1/2 pounds. The figures are presented as the books print them, without choosing between the accounts.
What should the head and bill look like?
Howard describes a short, small head, dark hazel eyes and a rather short bill. He gives the drake a dark yellowish green head and the duck a very dark, almost black head. Lamon and Slocum say the duck bill should be black and the drake bill very dark green.
What color is the plumage?
Both accounts make black the base color. Howard describes rich black plumage with a brilliant greenish tint throughout and says the upper parts show more green than the underparts. Lamon and Slocum say the color should be black throughout and warn especially against white in the breast of females.
Is it a sitting breed?
Yes, in both accounts. Howard calls the ducks splendid sitters and says they will steal their nests if permitted to do so. Lamon and Slocum list the Black East India among the broody breeds.
The books quoted here
- Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management, George E. Howard (1897; USDA Farmers' Bulletin No. 64). Full text and catalogue entry.
- Ducks and Geese, Harry M. Lamon and Rob R. Slocum (1922; Orange Judd Publishing Company, New York). Full text and catalogue entry.