Barnyard BreedsOld farm breeds, in the words of the old books

Chicken · breed notes

Cochin Chicken

Piper's 1877 poultry book gives one chapter to the Cochin-Chinas, or Shanghaes, as one breed with two names; Jennings's 1864 book, printed in Philadelphia, writes a Cochin China entry and a Shanghae entry and calls the two nearly related. Below is what each book says, quoted line by line, with the place where they disagree marked.

Where it comes from

Piper opens his Cochin chapter by saying the name is wrong. In his account these fowls came from Shanghae, not from Cochin-China, where he says they were comparatively unknown. He reports Mr. Fortune's opinion that they are a Chinese breed kept in great numbers at Shanghae, and says that attempts to give them the name of the port have failed, with most breeders still calling them Cochins. His chapter title, Cochin-Chinas, or Shanghaes, puts both names on one breed.

  • Like many other fowls these possess a name which is incorrectly applied, for they came from Shanghae, not Cochin-China, where they were comparatively unknown.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • Mr. Fortune, who, from his travels in China, is well qualified to give an opinion, states that they are a Chinese breed, kept in great numbers at ShanghaePiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
More from the books (1)
  • But all attempts to give them the name of the port from which they were brought have failed, and the majority of breeders persist in calling them Cochins.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide

Piper says the first Shanghae fowls brought to this country were sent from India to Her Majesty. By this country he means Britain, where his book was published (the title page says London). He dates their introduction to 1843, when the northern ports of China were thrown open to European vessels at the end of the Chinese war, but notes that some assign a date from 1844 to 1847. Those people, he writes, say the birds called Cochins that the Queen exhibited in 1843 were not the true breed, being entirely without feathers on the shanks and altogether different in form and general characteristics.

  • The first Shanghae fowls brought to this country were sent from India to Her Majesty, which gave them great importancePiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • They were first introduced into this country when the northern ports of China, including Shanghae, were thrown open to European vessels on the conclusion of the Chinese war in 1843Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • but some assign the date of their introduction from 1844 to 1847, and say that those called Cochins, exhibited by the Queen in 1843, were not the true breed, having been not only entirely without feathers on the shanks, but also altogether different in form and general characteristics.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide

Jennings brings the Queen in too, in his Cochin China entry, but words it as hearsay: the fowl are said to have been presented to Queen Victoria from the East Indies. That entry gives no year, and in it he does not say the Cochin China came from Shanghae. He writes instead that it differs very little in qualities, habits and general appearance from the Shanghaes, to which it is nearly related, and he keeps the two as separate entries. Elsewhere in the book he names the Shanghaes and the Cochin-Chinas side by side among the purer breeds.

  • The Cochin China fowl are said to have been presented to Queen Victoria from the East Indies.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • They differ very little in their qualities, habits, and general appearance from the Shanghaes, to which they are undoubtedly nearly related.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
More from the books (1)
  • the purer breeds, as the Shanghaes and the Cochin-ChinasJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry

How to recognise one

Piper puts the fluff first: a quantity of soft, long feathers over the thighs and the hinder parts, so that the broadest part of the bird is behind. He says its quality is a good indication of the breed. His list of points for a good cock is long: compact, large and square built, broad across the loins and hind-quarters, with a deep keel, a broad, short back and a short neck. He asks for a long hanging ear-lobe of pure red, white being inadmissible, and for stout legs set widely apart, yellow and heavily feathered to the toe. The one chief defect he names is narrowness of breast, and he says the hen's body is much deeper in proportion than the cock's.

  • a quantity of beautifully soft, long feathers, covering the thighs till they project considerably, and garnishing all the hinder parts of the bird in the same manner, so that the broadest part of the bird is behindPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • A good Cochin cock should be compact, large, and square built; broad across the loins and hind-quarters; with a deep keel; broad, short back; short neckPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • stout legs set widely apart, yellow and heavily feathered to the toePiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
More from the books (4)
  • Its quality is a good indication of the breedPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • long hanging ear-lobe, of pure red, white being inadmissiblePiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • The chief defect of the breed is narrowness of breastPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • The hen's body is much deeper in proportion than that of the cock.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide

In his Cochin China entry Jennings describes the cock's comb as large, upright, single and deeply indented, much like the Black Spanish's. He says the hen's build is nearest to the Dorking's, apart from a very small tail, and that both sexes are lower in the leg than the Black Spanish or the Malay. The comparisons are his own; this page adds none. In his Shanghae entry he gives heights: the full-grown cock, if a good specimen, stands about twenty-eight inches, and the female about twenty-two or twenty-three. He then says the chief characteristics of that variety are not the comb and wattles, nor even the reddish-yellow feathered leg, but the abundant, soft and downy covering of the thighs, hips and region of the vent, with a remarkably short tail.

  • The cock has a large, upright, single, deeply-indented comb, very much resembling that of the Black SpanishJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • The hen approaches in her build more nearly to the Dorking than to any other breed, except that the tail is very small and proportionately depressedJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • The cock, when full-grown, stands about twenty-eight inches high, if he is a good specimen; the female, about twenty-two or twenty-three inches.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
More from the books (2)
  • Both sexes are lower in the leg than either the Black Spanish or the Malay.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • the abundant, soft, and downy covering of the thighs, hips, and region of the vent, together with the remarkably short tailJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry

Colour is where the books give the most. Piper lists his principal colours as Buff, Cinnamon, Partridge, Grouse, Black and White, and says the Buff and White are the most popular. He adds that the Cinnamon comes in two shades, the Light Cinnamon and the Silver, and that the White and Black were introduced later than the others; his chapter describes the colours one by one and also mentions Cuckoo Cochins. Jennings writes of birds, not lists. In his Cochin China entry the cock is, in short, altogether a flame-colored bird, and the hen's coloring is flat, in various shades of very light brown with light yellow on the neck. In his White Shanghae entry the variety is entirely white, and he says it differs in no material respect from the red, yellow and Dominique, except in color.

  • The principal colours now bred are Buff, Cinnamon, Partridge, Grouse, Black, and White. The Buff and White are the most popular.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • It is, in short, altogether a flame-colored bird.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • This variety is entirely white, with the legs usually feathered, and differ in no material respect from the red, yellow, and Dominique, except in color.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
More from the books (4)
  • The Cinnamon are of two shades, the Light Cinnamon and the Silver, which is a pale washy tintPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • The White and Black were introduced later than the others.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • Cuckoo Cochins are marked like the Cuckoo DorkingsPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • Her coloring is flat, being composed of various shades of very light brown, with light yellow on the neck.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry

Temperament and habits

Piper rates the Cochin the best of all fowls for a limited space, and not inclined to wander even when given an extensive run. He says they cannot fly and that a fence three feet high will keep them in. On handling he writes that they will let you take them off their roost, examine them and put them back without struggling. He also calls them excellent sitters and mothers, and very hardy, with chickens easy to rear, doing well even in bleak places without any unusual care.

  • They cannot fly, and a fence three feet high will keep them in.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • They will let you take them off their roost, handle and examine them, and put them back without struggling.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • They are excellent sitters and mothers.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
More from the books (2)
  • They are the best of all fowls for a limited space, and not inclined to wander even when they have an extensive run.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • They are very hardy, and their chickens easy to rear, doing well even in bleak places without any unusual care.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide

On ageing, Piper writes that Cochins lose their beauty earlier than any other breed and moult with more difficulty each time, and he puts their greatest beauty at from nine to eighteen months old. He also says they are backward in fledging, with the chickens of immature fowls the most backward and the cockerels showing their flight feathers earliest, yet very early matured. For buyers he gives a short list of things to avoid: clean legs, fifth toes, which he says show a cross with the Dorking, double combs that betray Malay blood, and long tails.

  • Cochins lose their beauty earlier than any other breed, and moult with more difficulty each time. They are in their greatest beauty at from nine to eighteen months old.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
  • In buying Cochins avoid clean legs, fifth toes, which show that it has been crossed with the Dorking, double combs that betray Malay blood, and long tailsPiper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
More from the books (1)
  • But they are backward in fledging, chickens bred from immature fowls being the most backward. Those which are cockerels show their flight feathers earliest. They are very early matured.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide

Jennings, in his Cochin China entry, says the breed may safely be recommended to people living in the country. For the inhabitants of towns he finds it less desirable, because the light tone of its plumage would show every mark of dirt. In his White Shanghae entry he writes that, being more quiet in their habits and less inclined to ramble, the hens are invaluable as incubators and nurses. He adds that these fowls rank among the largest coming from China and are very thrifty in what he calls our climate, which for a book printed in Philadelphia means an American one.

  • For the inhabitants of towns it is less desirable, as the light tone of its plumage would show every mark of dirt and defilementJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • Being more quiet in their habits, and less inclined to ramble, the hens are invaluable as incubators and nursesJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
  • These fowls will rank among the largest coming from China, and are very thrifty in our climate.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry
More from the books (1)
  • it may safely be recommended to people residing in the countryJennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry

The two books side by side

PointPiper, 1877Jennings, 1864
NamesCochin-China, or Shanghae; in the United States the feather-legged were called Shanghaes, the clean-legged Cochins“In the United States both names are used, the feather-legged being called Shanghaes, and the clean-legged Cochins.” (Piper, 1877)Two entries, Cochin China and Shanghae, called nearly related“to which they are undoubtedly nearly related” (Jennings, 1864)
Where fromShanghae; Mr. Fortune: a Chinese breed kept in great numbers there“Mr. Fortune, who, from his travels in China, is well qualified to give an opinion, states that they are a Chinese breed, kept in great numbers at Shanghae” (Piper, 1877)Cochin China entry: said to have been presented to Queen Victoria from the East Indies“said to have been presented to Queen Victoria from the East Indies” (Jennings, 1864)
Feathered legsAvoid clean legs when buying“In buying Cochins avoid clean legs” (Piper, 1877)Cochin China entry: usually smooth-legged; the Shanghaes, generally, more or less heavily feathered“usually smooth-legged, while the Shanghaes, generally, are more or less heavily feathered” (Jennings, 1864)
Feathered legs, as describedThe cock's legs heavily feathered to the toe“yellow and heavily feathered to the toe” (Piper, 1877)Shanghae entry: mostly covered down the outside to the end of the toes, but not always“mostly covered down the outside, even to the end of the toes, with feathers. This last, however, is not always the case.” (Jennings, 1864)
Leg colourIn all the colours, yellow“The legs in all the colours should be yellow.” (Piper, 1877)Cochin China entry: some specimens yellow, which he calls objectionable“some specimens have them yellow, which is objectionable.” (Jennings, 1864)
CombRather small, single, erect“rather small, finely and evenly serrated, straight, single, erect comb” (Piper, 1877)Cochin China cock: large, upright, single, deeply indented“a large, upright, single, deeply-indented comb” (Jennings, 1864)
Ear-lobeLong and hanging, pure red; white inadmissible“long hanging ear-lobe, of pure red, white being inadmissible” (Piper, 1877)Cochin China cock: sometimes a very large white ear-hole on each cheek“he has sometimes a very large white ear-hole on each cheek” (Jennings, 1864)
Colours namedBuff, Cinnamon, Partridge, Grouse, Black and White“The principal colours now bred are Buff, Cinnamon, Partridge, Grouse, Black, and White.” (Piper, 1877)Cochin China cock: a flame-colored bird“It is, in short, altogether a flame-colored bird.” (Jennings, 1864)
Cock's weightNot less than ten or eleven pounds; a very fine bird thirteen“The cock ought not to weigh less than ten or eleven pounds, and a very fine bird will reach thirteen” (Piper, 1877)Shanghae entry: males at maturity, ten to twelve pounds“weighing, as the males do, at maturity, from ten to twelve pounds” (Jennings, 1864)
Hen's weightEight to ten pounds“the hens from eight to ten pounds” (Piper, 1877)Shanghae entry: females at maturity, seven and a half to eight and a half pounds“and the females from seven and a half to eight and a half” (Jennings, 1864)

Weights the two books give

Neither book prints a table of standard weights, so there is no table here. Piper gives a floor for the cock, who ought not to weigh less than ten or eleven pounds, and a figure for a very fine bird. Of the two Jennings lines, the first is from his Shanghae entry, which gives a range for mature males and females, and the second is from his White Shanghae entry, which gives one cock of eight pounds at about eight months. The cock figures differ, ten or eleven pounds and more in Piper against ten to twelve in Jennings, and so do the hens, eight to ten pounds in Piper against seven and a half to eight and a half in Jennings. Jennings's Cochin China entry gives no weight for the birds. The figures are not combined into one range and not converted, and this page does not guess why they differ.

As printed in Piper, 1877: The cock ought not to weigh less than ten or eleven pounds, and a very fine bird will reach thirteen; the hens from eight to ten pounds.

As printed in Jennings, 1864: weighing, as the males do, at maturity, from ten to twelve pounds, and the females from seven and a half to eight and a half

As printed in Jennings, 1864: A cock of this variety attained a weight of eight pounds, at about the age of eight months

Where the two books disagree

Both books say something about leg colour, and they point opposite ways. Piper writes that the legs in all the colours should be yellow. In his Cochin China entry Jennings says that some specimens have yellow legs and calls that objectionable. Piper's line covers the breed he calls Cochin-Chinas, or Shanghaes; Jennings's line is from his Cochin China entry only. This page does not say which is right.

The legs in all the colours should be yellow.Piper, 1877, Poultry: A Practical Guide
some specimens have them yellow, which is objectionable.Jennings, 1864, Sheep, Swine, and Poultry

Questions readers ask

What colors do Cochin chickens come in?

Only the colours the two books name. Piper lists his principal colours as Buff, Cinnamon, Partridge, Grouse, Black and White, and says the Buff and White are the most popular. He adds that the Cinnamon comes in two shades, the Light Cinnamon and the Silver, and his chapter also mentions Cuckoo Cochins. Jennings writes by entry rather than by list. In his Cochin China entry the cock is altogether a flame-colored bird and the hen is in various shades of very light brown with light yellow on the neck, and in his White Shanghae entry the variety is entirely white, differing in no material respect from the red, yellow and Dominique except in color. This page lists only the colours these passages name; Piper's chapter describes each of his colours at more length.

Where do Cochin chickens come from?

The two books answer differently, and both bring in the Queen. Piper says the name Cochin-China is incorrectly applied: in his account the fowls came from Shanghae, and Mr. Fortune states that they are a Chinese breed kept in great numbers there. He says the first Shanghae fowls brought to this country (Britain, where his book was published) were sent from India to Her Majesty, and that they were first introduced when the northern ports of China were thrown open to European vessels in 1843, though some assign 1844 to 1847. In his Cochin China entry Jennings says that the fowl are said to have been presented to Queen Victoria from the East Indies, and that they are nearly related to the Shanghaes. This page does not decide between them.

How big do Cochin chickens get?

The books give different figures, and each one is tied to its source. Piper says the cock ought not to weigh less than ten or eleven pounds and a very fine bird will reach thirteen, and the hens from eight to ten pounds. Jennings, in his Shanghae entry, gives males at maturity as from ten to twelve pounds and females from seven and a half to eight and a half, and the full-grown cock as about twenty-eight inches high and the female about twenty-two or twenty-three. In his White Shanghae entry a cock of that variety attained a weight of eight pounds at about eight months. His Cochin China entry gives no weight for the birds. The figures are not combined or converted here, and this page does not guess why they differ.

Do Cochin chickens have feathered feet?

The two books point different ways. Piper describes the cock's legs as yellow and heavily feathered to the toe and tells buyers to avoid clean legs. He also records that in the United States both names are used, the feather-legged being called Shanghaes and the clean-legged Cochins. Jennings says in his Cochin China entry that the breed is usually smooth-legged while the Shanghaes, generally, are more or less heavily feathered. In his Shanghae entry the legs are mostly covered down the outside, even to the end of the toes, with feathers, and he adds that this is not always the case; in his White Shanghae entry the legs are usually feathered. This page prints them side by side and does not pick one.

The books quoted here