Barnyard BreedsOld farm breeds, in the words of the old books

Goose · breed notes

Chinese Goose

The Chinese is the small goose with a large knob on its head, a long arched neck and an upright carriage. Howard (1897) and Lamon and Slocum (1922) each give it an entry, and the lines in quotation marks come straight from those pages. The two give different standard weights for the grown birds, and Lamon and Slocum make two separate statements about sitting.

Where it comes from

Where the breed came from is not stated in either book's entry on the Chinese. Howard writes that there are two varieties, the Brown and the White. Lamon and Slocum give the same two names in their list of the standard geese, and add that the Chinese is the one breed in that list made up of two varieties.

  • There are two varieties of Chinese geese--the Brown (fig. 32) and the White.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • the two varieties of the Chinese as the Brown Chinese and the White ChineseLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

Howard calls it the smallest of the goose breeds and says it averages 6 to 7 pounds under the ones he has already named. Lamon and Slocum call it quite different in type from the three breeds that precede it in their list, much smaller and set higher on the legs. They also put it probably third in numbers, and say it is sometimes classed with the ornamental geese because of its smaller size.

  • averaging in weight from 6 to 7 pounds lighter than those previously namedHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • The Chinese is quite different in type from the three preceding breeds.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (2)
  • The Chinese geese are probably third most numerous in numbersLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
  • Chinese are sometimes classed as ornamental geese on account of their smaller sizeLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

How to recognise one

Howard opens his description by calling the breed exceedingly graceful in appearance and quite hardy. He gives it large heads, a medium-length bill, and long necks that are gracefully arched. The back is medium in length and the breast round and full. In Lamon and Slocum's entry the body carries itself much more upright than in the breeds before it, and the neck is long and slender.

  • They are exceedingly graceful in appearance, quite hardyHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (2)
  • and long, gracefully arched necks. The backs are medium in length, and the breast is round and fullHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • The neck is long and slender and the head has a large knob.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

Howard names the Chinese as one of just two breeds with a knob. Lamon and Slocum want a very slender neck and a very large knob, the larger the better. They add that the knob tends to run small when the neck is slender, and that the two are difficult to secure together in perfection.

  • and are the only two breeds that have the knob on the headHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • An important part about the type is to secure a very slender neck, another important point being to secure a very large knob; the larger this is the better.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
  • a decided tendency for the knob to run small when the neck is slender and it is difficult to secure in perfection the combination of a very slender neck and a large knobLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

The side-by-side table below lines up the colour points of the two varieties. In short, Howard gives the Brown a brown head, a knob of dark brown or black, and a neck with a dark stripe, while the White is pure white with an orange knob and bill. Lamon and Slocum want a rich brown in the Brown, with a stripe that stands out from the neck colour, and a pure white in the White.

  • neck light brown or grayish brown, with a dark stripe from the head down to the bodyHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (2)
  • The knob and bill are orange colorHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • The plumage should be a rich brown shade of color, a faded gray color being very undesirable.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

Temperament and habits

Lamon and Slocum write about the noise of geese in general, saying the cry is hoarse and rasping and may annoy a person with bad nerves. They then say the Chinese geese are the noisiest of the lot. Howard's entry on the Chinese does not mention noise.

On sitting, Lamon and Slocum say two different things in two places. In the first they count every goose breed but one as broody, and the Chinese is not the one left out. In the second they name the Chinese, together with one other breed, as perhaps the least broody and sometimes called non-broody. Howard's entry on the Chinese does not mention sitting.

  • may be classed as broody breeds, that is to say, they will make their nests and hatch their young if given a chance to do soLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
  • Chinese are perhaps the least broody of the breeds and are sometimes termed non-broody.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

The two varieties side by side

PointBrown ChineseWhite Chinese
PlumageA rich brown; a faded gray is very undesirable“The plumage should be a rich brown shade of color, a faded gray color being very undesirable.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)Pure white, free from feathers of any other color“is pure white throughout, perfectly free from feathers of any other color” (Howard, 1897)
HeadBrown“The color of head of the Brown Chinese geese is brown” (Howard, 1897)Not described in either book
KnobDark brown or black“knob dark brown or black” (Howard, 1897)Orange“The knob in this variety should be orange” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
Knob colour faultInjury or freezing may turn it yellow, which is undesirable“injury or freezing may turn the knob yellow which is undesirable” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)Any tendency toward yellow to be avoided“any tendency toward yellow should be avoided” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
NeckLight brown or grayish brown, with a dark stripe down to the body“neck light brown or grayish brown, with a dark stripe from the head down to the body” (Howard, 1897)Not described in either book
Neck stripeWell defined, and in distinct contrast with the rest of the neck colour“The stripe down the back of the neck should be well defined and should be distinctly in contrast with the rest of the neck color.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)Not described in either book
BillDark brown or black“bill dark brown or black” (Howard, 1897)Orange“The knob and bill are orange color” (Howard, 1897)
EyesHazel or brown“The eyes are hazel or brown” (Howard, 1897)Deep leaden blue“The eyes are a deep leaden blue.” (Howard, 1897)
Shanks, toes, websDusky orange“shanks, toes, and webs are a dusky orange color” (Howard, 1897)Orange, like the knob and bill“The knob and bill are orange color, as are also the shanks, toes, and web.” (Howard, 1897)
Feathers to avoidWhite feathers in the primaries or secondaries“White feathers in the primaries or secondaries must be avoided.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)Not described in either book
Young birdsNot described in either bookOccasional young females may show slate in the back; almost invariably gone after the first moult“Occasional young females may show slate in the back but this is not serious as it almost invariably disappears with the first moult.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)

Old standard weights

BookAdult ganderAdult gooseYoung ganderYoung goose
Howard, 189714 lb12 lb10 lb8 lb
Lamon & Slocum, 192212 lb10 lb10 lb8 lb

Two of the standards are the same in both books: the young gander is 10 pounds and the young goose 8. The adult figures are not. Howard gives 14 pounds for the adult gander and 12 for the adult goose, where Lamon and Slocum give 12 and 10. In the 1922 row the quote marks stand for lbs., as ditto marks. Neither the 1897 sentence nor the 1922 table says why the adult figures differ.

As printed in Howard, 1897: The standard weight of the adult gander is 14 pounds; adult goose, 12 pounds; young gander, 10 pounds, and young goose, 8 pounds.

As printed in Lamon & Slocum, 1922: Chinese 12 " 10 " 10 " 8 "

Where the two books disagree

For the grown birds the two books give different standards: the 1897 bulletin has 14 pounds for the gander and 12 for the goose, and the 1922 table has 12 and 10.

The standard weight of the adult gander is 14 pounds; adult goose, 12 poundsHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
Chinese 12 " 10 " 10 " 8 "Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

Questions readers ask

Where does the Chinese goose come from?

Neither book's entry on the Chinese says. Howard titles his entry Brown and White Chinese geese, while the one in Lamon and Slocum is titled The Chinese. Each gives the two variety names.

How big is a Chinese goose?

Howard calls it the smallest of the goose breeds and gives its average as 6 to 7 pounds under the breeds he has named before it. In Lamon and Slocum it is much smaller than the three breeds ahead of it. For the old standard weights, see the table below, where the adult figures differ between the two books and the young ones match.

Does a Chinese goose have a knob on its head?

Yes. Howard gives it a large knob and says only two breeds have one. Lamon and Slocum say a very large knob is wanted, and that the knob tends to run small when the neck is slender.

Is the Chinese goose a noisy bird?

Lamon and Slocum say the Chinese geese are the noisiest, after saying that geese in general make a good deal of noise. Howard's entry on the Chinese does not mention noise.

Does a Chinese goose sit on a nest?

Lamon and Slocum answer in two ways. One passage counts all the goose breeds but one as broody, and the Chinese is not the exception. Another says the Chinese are perhaps the least broody of the breeds and are sometimes termed non-broody. Howard's entry on the Chinese does not mention it.

The books quoted here