Barnyard BreedsOld farm breeds, in the words of the old books

Goose · breed notes

Wild Goose

Howard calls this bird the Gray Wild goose, and Lamon and Slocum call it the Wild or Canadian, with the Gray as its one variety. Each of two old books about ducks and geese has an entry on it, and the quotations on this page are copied exactly from the two books. They set all standard weights differently, and they disagree about how common the bird was.

Where it comes from

Neither book's entry on the Wild goose says where the breed came from. What the books give is the name, and the two use different ones. Howard heads his entry Gray Wild geese and lists the breed as Gray Wild among his standard geese. Lamon and Slocum write the Wild or Canadian in their list of six standard geese and give the Gray as the name of its single variety. Neither book explains the name.

  • Gray Toulouse, White Embden, Gray African, Brown Chinese, White Chinese, Gray Wild, and Colored EgyptianHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • There are six standard breeds of geese consisting of the following: Toulouse, Embden, African, Chinese, Wild or Canadian and Egyptian.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
  • All of these breeds consist of a single variety with the exception of the Chinese which is composed of two.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

The two books speak very differently about how often the bird was kept. Howard says the Gray Wild geese are among the best known of the domestic geese and are very generally bred over the whole of the country he is writing about. Lamon and Slocum, when they discuss the breeds of geese in general, put the Wild or Canadian together with the Egyptian. They say the two are more in the nature of ornamental breeds, not so commonly kept, and that neither is to be found in any great numbers.

  • Gray Wild geese (fig. 33) are among the best known of domestic geese, and are very generally bred throughout the entire country.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • The Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian are more in the nature of ornamental breeds since they are not so commonly kept and are principally to be found where ornamental water-fowls are maintained.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
  • Neither the Canadian nor the Egyptians are to be found in any great numbersLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

How to recognise one

Howard describes a rather small head with a small bill that is sharp at the point, and a long slender neck that he calls snaky in appearance. The back is long and rather narrow and arched from the neck to the tail. The body is long and somewhat slender, and the wings are long, large and powerful. Lamon and Slocum say the bird is smaller than the other breeds they have named, set much higher on its legs, with a neat, trim body that is oblong and carried in a horizontal position, and a neck that is long and slender.

  • These geese have a rather small head, small bill, sharp at the point, and long, slender neck, snaky in appearance.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • In type a Canadian goose is quite different from that of the other breeds mentioned. It is smaller, set much higher on legs and its body is neater and trimmer, and is oblong and carried in a horizontal position. The neck is long and slender.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (2)
  • The back is long and rather narrow, and is arched from neck to tailHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • body long and somewhat slender. The wings are long, large, and powerfulHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management

Only Howard gives colours. The head is black with a white stripe nearly covering the side of the face, and the bill and the neck are black, while the back is dark gray. The breast is light gray and grows darker toward the legs, and the underparts from the legs to the tail are white. The tail feathers are glossy black. He gives the shanks, toes, webs and eyes as black. Lamon and Slocum's entry on the Wild or Canadian names no colours, apart from calling the variety the Gray and saying the birds breed very true in type and color.

  • The head of the Wild goose is black, with a white stripe nearly covering the side of the face; bill, black; neck, black; and back, dark gray.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (3)
  • The breast is light gray, which grows darker as it approaches the legsHoward, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • The shanks, toes, and webs are black. The eyes are black.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
  • These birds breed very true in type and colorLamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

Temperament and habits

Lamon and Slocum open their entry with a surprise. Contrary to expectation, they say, the breed is very peaceable and very tame once it has been domesticated. They go on to say that the birds often tend to grow uneasy when the migratory season comes. Howard's entry on the Gray Wild does not mention temper at all. Lamon and Slocum also describe how keepers stopped the birds from flying off, and this page does not repeat those instructions.

  • Contrary to expectation this breed when domesticated is very peaceable and very tame.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
  • There is often, however, a tendency for them to grow uneasy when the migratory season comes.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

On pairing, Lamon and Slocum say the birds mate only in pairs as a rule. In their general passage on how geese are mated, they say the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian pair only in most cases. That second sentence names the two breeds together, so it is not a statement about the Wild goose alone. Howard's entry on the Gray Wild does not mention how the birds are mated.

More from the books (1)
  • The Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian geese in most cases pair only.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

The two books side by side

PointHoward, 1897Lamon & Slocum, 1922
NameGray Wild geese“GRAY WILD GEESE.” (Howard, 1897)The Wild or Canadian, with the Gray as its variety“the Wild or Canadian as the Gray” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
Head and billRather small head; small bill, sharp at the point“a rather small head, small bill, sharp at the point” (Howard, 1897)Not described in this book
NeckLong and slender, snaky in appearance“long, slender neck, snaky in appearance” (Howard, 1897)Long and slender“The neck is long and slender.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
BodyLong and somewhat slender“body long and somewhat slender” (Howard, 1897)Neater and trimmer, oblong, carried in a horizontal position“its body is neater and trimmer, and is oblong and carried in a horizontal position” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
LegsThighs rather short“the thighs are rather short” (Howard, 1897)Set much higher on the legs“It is smaller, set much higher on legs” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
WingsLong, large and powerful“The wings are long, large, and powerful” (Howard, 1897)Not described in this book
PlumageHead black with a white stripe; back dark gray; underparts white; tail glossy black“The head of the Wild goose is black, with a white stripe nearly covering the side of the face” (Howard, 1897)Not described in this book
Shanks, toes, webs and eyesBlack“The shanks, toes, and webs are black. The eyes are black.” (Howard, 1897)Not described in this book
TemperamentNot described in this bookVery peaceable and very tame when domesticated“when domesticated is very peaceable and very tame” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)
How commonAmong the best known of domestic geese“are among the best known of domestic geese” (Howard, 1897)More in the nature of ornamental breeds; not so commonly kept“more in the nature of ornamental breeds since they are not so commonly kept” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922)

Old standard weights

BookAdult ganderAdult gooseYoung ganderYoung goose
Howard, 189716 lb14 lb12 lb10 lb
Lamon & Slocum, 192212 lb10 lb10 lb8 lb

The two books differ on all standards. Howard gives 16 pounds for the adult gander, where Lamon and Slocum give 12. For the adult goose it is 14 against 10, for the young gander 12 against 10, and for the young goose 10 against 8. In the 1922 row the quote marks stand for lbs., as ditto marks. Neither the 1897 sentence nor the 1922 row says why the figures differ.

As printed in Howard, 1897: The standard weight of the adult gander is 16 pounds; adult goose, 14 pounds; young gander, 12 pounds, and young goose, 10 pounds.

As printed in Lamon & Slocum, 1922: Wild or Canadian 12 " 10 " 10 " 8 "

Where the two books disagree

Howard writes that the Gray Wild geese are among the best known of domestic geese and very generally bred over the country. Lamon and Slocum, speaking of the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian together, call them more in the nature of ornamental breeds and not so commonly kept. The 1922 sentence names both breeds, so it is not about the Wild goose alone. Neither book gives a reason for the difference or refers to the other on the point.

Gray Wild geese (fig. 33) are among the best known of domestic geese, and are very generally bred throughout the entire country.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
The Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian are more in the nature of ornamental breeds since they are not so commonly kept and are principally to be found where ornamental water-fowls are maintained.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese

Questions readers ask

What is the Wild goose called in the old books?

The two books use different names. Howard heads his entry Gray Wild geese. Lamon and Slocum call the breed the Wild or Canadian and give the Gray as the name of its single variety.

Is the Wild goose tame?

Lamon and Slocum say that, contrary to expectation, the breed is very peaceable and very tame when domesticated. They add that the birds often tend to grow uneasy when the migratory season comes. Howard's entry on the Gray Wild does not mention temper.

What does a Wild goose look like?

Howard describes a rather small head, a small bill sharp at the point, a long slender neck and a long, rather narrow back. Lamon and Slocum say it is smaller than the other breeds, set much higher on its legs, and oblong in body, carried in a horizontal position. Both books call the neck long and slender.

Was the Wild goose a common bird?

It depends on the book. Howard says the Gray Wild geese are among the best known of domestic geese and are very generally bred. Lamon and Slocum put the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian together, calling them more in the nature of ornamental breeds that are not so commonly kept. Neither book gives a reason for the difference.

Do Wild geese mate in pairs?

Lamon and Slocum say the birds mate only in pairs as a rule. In another passage they say the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian pair only in most cases. Howard's entry on the Gray Wild does not mention mating.

The books quoted here