Goose · breed notes
Egyptian Goose
Howard calls this bird the Colored Egyptian and also records the name Nile Goose, while Lamon and Slocum call it the Egyptian and give the Colored as the name of its single variety. Each of two old books about ducks and geese has an entry on it, and the quotations on this page are copied exactly from those books. They set all standard weights differently, and they describe its place among the geese in different words.
Names and standing
Neither book's entry on the Egyptian says where the breed came from, and neither explains its names. What the books give is the names themselves. Howard heads his entry Colored Egyptian geese. He adds that the birds are sometimes called the Nile Goose. Lamon and Slocum list six standard geese that end with the Egyptian, and they give the Colored as the name of its one variety.
They are sometimes called the Nile Goose.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Managementthe Egyptian as the Colored
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
Howard says what the bird was bred for, not how common it was: the Colored Egyptians are purely ornamental and have been bred, in the country he is writing about, only for the showroom. Lamon and Slocum, when they run through the geese in general, put the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian into one sentence, and in a second sentence of the same kind they say that neither is to be found in any great numbers.
they are purely ornamental, not having been bred in this country for any other purpose than the showroom.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (1)
Neither the Canadian nor the Egyptians are to be found in any great numbers
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
How to recognise one
Howard stresses height and grace. He calls the goose tall and somewhat slender, and says this gives it an elegance that no other breed has. His description goes on to a head of medium size and rather long, a bill of medium length, a rather small neck and a narrow back, with a round breast and a body that is long but somewhat small and slender. The wings are large and carry horny spurs in place of the usual hard knobs.
This goose is tall and somewhat slender, which gives it an elegance of appearance not possessed by any other breed.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
More from the books (2)
a medium-sized and rather long head, a bill of medium length, and a rather small neck
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementTheir wings are large, and have instead of the ordinary hard knobs horny spurs about five-eighths of an inch long
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
Lamon and Slocum begin from size and measure the bird against the Canadian goose, the one breed they say it most resembles. It is the smallest of their standard geese. Its legs are a little longer than the Canadian's, so more of the thigh shows under the body, and the body slopes down slightly from breast to tail instead of being held almost level. The neck is not as long, or quite as slender, as the Canadian's.
This is the smallest of the standard breeds of geese.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and GeeseIn type it more nearly approaches the Canadian than any other breed but it is somewhat longer in legs, showing more of the thigh beneath the body.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
The neck is neither so long nor quite so slender as that of the Canadian.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
Howard gives the colours in detail: a black and gray head, a purple or bluish red bill, orange eyes, a chestnut centre to the breast, glossy black tail feathers and reddish yellow shanks, toes and webs. He also calls it the most beautiful of the breeds of geese, which is a verdict on looks. Lamon and Slocum make a narrower remark about colour alone: it is the brightest colored of any of the geese, and it breeds fairly true in color and markings.
The color of the head is black and gray; the bill is purple or bluish red, and the eyes orange.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThis breed is the brightest colored of any of the geese and breeds fairly true in color and markings.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (2)
The tail feathers are glossy black; thighs, pale buff; shanks, toes, and webs, reddish yellow.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementThe most beautiful of the breeds of geese are the colored Egyptians
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
Temperament and habits
Only Howard writes about the Egyptian's temper. He calls the bird of a most quarrelsome nature and says a male will fight a male of its own kind to the death, so each male needs a pen to itself. He picks his words with care: it is seldom, not never, that two males can share a pen. Lamon and Slocum's entry on the Egyptian does not mention quarrelling or fighting. It says only that the bird is likely to become uneasy at times.
It can generally be bred in confinement, but is of a most quarrelsome nature, and the male will fight to the death other males of the same species.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and ManagementLike the Canadian the Egyptian goose is likely to become uneasy at times
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
The males must each be given a separate pen, and mated with the females; it is seldom that any two males can be kept in the same pen.
Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
Lamon and Slocum say in the Egyptian entry that the birds pair only, as the Canadian does. Their general passage on how geese are paired uses a softer phrase, in most cases, and it names the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian together, so it is not a statement about the Egyptian alone.
Like the Canadian the Egyptians mate in pairs only
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
More from the books (1)
The Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian geese in most cases pair only.
Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
The two books side by side
| Point | Howard, 1897 | Lamon & Slocum, 1922 |
|---|---|---|
| Name | Colored Egyptian geese“COLORED EGYPTIAN GEESE.” (Howard, 1897) | The Egyptian, with the Colored as its variety“the Egyptian as the Colored” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Size | Tall and somewhat slender“This goose is tall and somewhat slender” (Howard, 1897) | The smallest of the standard breeds of geese“This is the smallest of the standard breeds of geese.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Legs | Thighs of medium length; shanks rather long“the thighs are of medium length, and the shanks rather long” (Howard, 1897) | Somewhat longer than the Canadian, showing more thigh“it is somewhat longer in legs, showing more of the thigh beneath the body” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Body | Long, but somewhat small and slender“body, long, but somewhat small and slender” (Howard, 1897) | Slopes downward slightly from breast to tail“slopes downward slightly from the breast to the tail” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Neck | Rather small“a rather small neck” (Howard, 1897) | Not so long nor quite so slender as the Canadian's“The neck is neither so long nor quite so slender as that of the Canadian.” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Colour | Head black and gray; bill purple or bluish red; eyes orange“The color of the head is black and gray; the bill is purple or bluish red, and the eyes orange.” (Howard, 1897) | The brightest colored of any of the geese; breeds fairly true“This breed is the brightest colored of any of the geese and breeds fairly true in color and markings” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Wing spurs | Horny spurs about five-eighths of an inch long“horny spurs about five-eighths of an inch long” (Howard, 1897) | Not described in this book |
| Temperament | Of a most quarrelsome nature“is of a most quarrelsome nature” (Howard, 1897) | Likely to become uneasy at times“is likely to become uneasy at times” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
| Standing | Purely ornamental“they are purely ornamental” (Howard, 1897) | With the Wild or Canadian: more in the nature of ornamental breeds; not so commonly kept“more in the nature of ornamental breeds since they are not so commonly kept” (Lamon & Slocum, 1922) |
Old standard weights
| Book | Adult gander | Adult goose | Young gander | Young goose |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Howard, 1897 | 15 lb | 12 lb | 12 lb | 9 lb |
| Lamon & Slocum, 1922 | 10 lb | 8 lb | 8 lb | 6 lb |
The two books differ on all standards, and Howard's figure is the heavier each time. He gives 15 pounds for the adult gander, where Lamon and Slocum give 10. For the adult goose it is 12 against 8, for the young gander 12 against 8, and for the young goose 9 against 6. In the 1922 row the quote marks stand for lbs., as ditto marks. Neither the 1897 sentence nor the 1922 row says why the figures differ.
As printed in Howard, 1897: The standard weight of the adult gander is 15 pounds; adult goose, 12 pounds; young gander, 12 pounds, and young goose, 9 pounds.
As printed in Lamon & Slocum, 1922: Egyptian 10 " 8 " 8 " 6 "
Where the two books disagree
Howard is flat about it: the Colored Egyptians are purely ornamental, and in the country he is writing about they were bred for the showroom and nothing else. Lamon and Slocum leave room. Speaking of the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian together, they say the two are more in the nature of ornamental breeds, and they say where such birds are principally to be found. The reasons differ as well: Howard speaks of what the birds were bred for, Lamon and Slocum of how commonly they were kept. The 1922 sentence names both breeds, so it is not about the Egyptian alone. Neither book refers to the other on the point.
they are purely ornamental, not having been bred in this country for any other purpose than the showroom.Howard, 1897, Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management
The Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian are more in the nature of ornamental breeds since they are not so commonly kept and are principally to be found where ornamental water-fowls are maintained.Lamon & Slocum, 1922, Ducks and Geese
Questions readers ask
What is the Egyptian goose called in the old books?
Howard heads his entry Colored Egyptian geese and says the birds are sometimes called the Nile Goose. Lamon and Slocum call the breed the Egyptian and give the Colored as the name of its one variety. Neither entry says where the breed came from.
Is the Egyptian goose a quarrelsome bird?
Howard says it is of a most quarrelsome nature and that a male will fight other males of its kind to the death, so each male must have a separate pen. He adds that it is seldom that any two males can be kept in the same pen. Lamon and Slocum's entry on the Egyptian does not mention quarrelling or fighting; it says the bird is likely to become uneasy at times.
How big is the Egyptian goose?
The books stress different things. Howard calls it tall and somewhat slender, though he also calls the body long but somewhat small and slender. Lamon and Slocum call it the smallest of the standard breeds of geese, with legs a little longer than the Canadian's. The standard weights are given further down the page.
What colour is the Egyptian goose?
Howard describes a black and gray head, a purple or bluish red bill, orange eyes, a chestnut centre to the breast and reddish yellow shanks, toes and webs. Lamon and Slocum give no colours in detail; they say it is the brightest colored of any of the geese and breeds fairly true in color and markings.
Was the Egyptian goose a common bird?
Howard does not say how common it was. He says only what it was bred for: it is purely ornamental, and in the country he is writing about it was bred for the showroom and nothing else. Lamon and Slocum put the Wild or Canadian and the Egyptian together, calling them more in the nature of ornamental breeds that are not so commonly kept.
The books quoted here
- Ducks and Geese: Standard Breeds and Management, George E. Howard (1897; USDA Farmers' Bulletin No. 64). Full text and catalogue entry.
- Ducks and Geese, Harry M. Lamon and Rob R. Slocum (1922; Orange Judd Publishing Company, New York). Full text and catalogue entry.